Recent action by major fast-food restaurants chains to remove fresh onions from their menus have highlighted a persistent challenge in food safety: fresh produce presents more significant contamination risks than beef, according to The Western Producer. This reality came into sharp focus following a widespread E. coli outbreak linked to McDonald’s onions that affected 90 people across the Midwest and western United States, resulting in one death.
The incident, which prompted McDonald’s to remove Quarter Pounders from approximately 2,800 of its U.S. locations, is a stark reminder of how vulnerable fresh produce supply chains remain to contamination. This stands in marked contrast to the beef industry, which has made significant strides in safety since the 1990s.
The transformation in beef safety can be traced back to a watershed moment: the 1992 Jack in the Box E. coli outbreak that infected 732 people, hospitalized more than 170 of those, and claimed four lives. The crisis spurred federal health regulators to implement stringent controls on beef processing, dramatically reducing the frequency of beef-related outbreaks. However, produce has proven to be a more complex challenge.
The fundamental difference lies in a simple fact: beef is cooked, while fresh produce is not. According to food safety experts, proper cooking serves as a “silver bullet” against contamination. Fresh produce, by its very nature, lacks this crucial safety step.
Despite sophisticated washing, sanitizing, and testing protocols that mirror those used in beef processing, produce remains vulnerable to contamination at levels too low for detection. The outdoor growing environment presents numerous contamination risks, from wildlife feces to agricultural runoff. E. coli, naturally present in animal intestines, can spread through various wildlife species including geese, boars, and deer, though cattle remain the primary carriers.
Multiple contamination points exist in produce production: untreated manure use, contaminated irrigation water, or improper handling during processing. Even industry leaders like McDonald’s and its supplier Taylor Farms, despite their reputation for rigorous safety standards, can face these challenges. McDonald’s has confirmed that its suppliers conducted regular testing during the outbreak period but failed to detect the specific E. coli strain involved.
This isn’t an isolated incident in the fast-food industry. Wendy’s faced a similar crisis in 2022, removing lettuce from several states after an E. coli outbreak. Taco Bell encountered comparable issues in 2006 when lettuce was linked to an outbreak affecting 71 people. The scope of produce-related food safety concerns extends beyond bacterial pathogens – McDonald’s previously dealt with a parasitic outbreak in 2018 that sickened nearly 400 people through contaminated salads.
The Food Safety Modernization Act of 2011 attempted to address these challenges by establishing the first comprehensive standards for fruit and vegetable production. However, according to a former FDA official, while government regulation effectively tackled beef contamination, produce safety might be better addressed through buyer-driven initiatives. Major purchasers like fast-food chains and grocery stores could collectively establish and standardize supplier requirements, particularly important given the fragmented nature of the produce market.
Testing remains a critical but imperfect tool. Mansour Samadpour, CEO of IEH Laboratories and Consulting Group, notes that testing becomes increasingly challenging as products become cleaner, making low-level contamination harder to detect. His work with USDA officials led to dramatic improvements in beef safety, reducing recalls from multiple monthly occurrences to one every few years. While similar testing rigor is applied to produce, the inherent challenges remain.
Ironically, while radiation treatment could effectively eliminate microbes in produce, it faces practical and cultural barriers. Samadpour points out that radiation treatment is not only impractical at the massive scale of produce distribution but also faces consumer resistance due to negative perceptions about irradiated food.
The ongoing challenges with produce safety underscore a crucial reality in the food industry: despite technological advances and stringent protocols, some risks remain inherently harder to control than others. While the beef industry has largely conquered its safety challenges through cooking requirements and regulatory oversight, the produce sector continues to grapple with the fundamental challenge of delivering fresh, uncooked products safely to consumers.
Commenting on this article, one national E. coli lawyer said, “As fast-food chains and other major buyers navigate these challenges, they must balance food safety concerns with consumer demands for fresh, unprocessed ingredients. However, the recent onion-related outbreak is a strong reminder that in the complex world of food safety, some of the simplest foods can present the most sophisticated challenges.”
